Harbor View Hotel Edgartown

rosewood

I want to book the Cape Cod, The Islands and Newport tour but I am worried about the bad reviews given for the Harbor View Hotel - dirty, smelly, old, etc. Can anyone advise me about this hotel? Trip Advisor has mixed reviews.

Claudia Sails

Any hotel is going to have some negative reviews - especially if hundreds have been submitted. You might read through all the forum threads and reviews for the tour on this site and see if anything pops up. We've always been happy with Tauck hotels, but there's always a chance of problems anywhere.

CaitlinMagner

The Harbor View was my favorite hotel on this trip! I don't understand the negative reviews, although maybe I had a renovated room and others didn't? The food was wonderful and the atmosphere just right for Martha's Vineyard. Fantastic location.

rhgramsay

The Harbor View was they only hotel on this tour which I thought up to Tauck standards, the rest. especially the Sea Crest were not good.

PureLuxury

I've stayed at Harbor View during summer visits to Martha's Vineyard....I've never had a bad experience or sub-standard room....

happytravelers20

I'm worried about the first hotel the Sea View Beach Hotel. The reviews are absolutely awful including recent ones. Why would Tauck use a hotel that gets such awful reviews for important things like cleanliness?? Has anyone stayed there?

British

There have been many poor reviews about the New England Tours with Tauck in general. They do chose the best available hotels but there are not many of them.

voikk32

Actually there are some very lovely places in the New England area but they might not accept groups as large as Tauck's

CathieOK

We are on this tour right now. We have absolutely no problems with the hotels. In Harbor View right now and it is lovely. We had a fantastic dinner. We could order anything on the menu. Needless to say, my husband ordered the $80 filet, just because he could.
Our tour guide, Tess has been great. I would not hesitate to recommend this trip.